Poetry rhyme battle of right and wrong

Guangzhou the poet Liu Zhong seedlings brother to the capital, last night broke the news in the "dream Taoyuan Restaurant (not economists Zou Hengfu Peking University Dean Head of indecent behavior in a) hosted a dinner invite nearly twenty how much with poetry dip side of friends from all walks of life, drinking about poetry. In the Poetry of the issue, the occurrence of the controversy: it was argued that the poem to Italy, first, not to legal harm intended; and was advocated metrical poetry must be strictly metrical, give board games, for example, does not allow for rules, the game will not be able to carried out and so on.
This controversy is neither fresh nor new ideas. Throughout the ages, do not know how many people have this fierce arguments, and even throwing punches opposite.
First, the disease dumb (sore throat, or said, "Beijing cough"), two seat multi elderly, more strangers, I take the walls of the concept of gesture, silent. Liu Jun, a few times so I express an opinion, were waved declined.
Of course, I did not practice to a transfixed heart, such as the realm of the Furui, hearts or ideas. The idea is not new, but then if I bluntly said, it is estimated that the feast atmosphere immediately to the destruction of the sweep argue both sides Drinking talking about spirits.
Mean I want to say, does not favor any party to the controversy is confused officer to settle a lawsuit the routine, each playing four top ten board. On two points:
First, if only metrical requirements in line with the tonal pattern, rhyme, antithesis, implication, emotional, literary grace is weak, at best, can only be regarded as text stacking game, killing time, entertain can come up with to show to others, say that this poetry, only laughable;
Second, to break the metrical, the king metrical hinder implication, emotional, literary grace when, otherwise, no reason to sacrifice metrical, do they talk about the rhyme speak tonal pattern, the antithesis of the ancient poetry not as a direct or even sentence length, all can not rhyme pay attention to the vernacular poetry, or even to write essays and novels.
The history of poetry, strict compliance with the the metrical and breakthrough metrical metrical poetry, have had outstanding works of many well-known. To Tang Dynasty the strict metrical's good poetry: Wang Wei's "An Autumn Evening in the Mountains" Li Bai "early onset Baidicheng, Du Fu customer to". Such works, and the list goes on.
Breakthrough metrical, there are some masterpieces. Example: Cui Hao's "Yellow Crane Tower", after the Fourth sentence metrical poetry, but the first four ancients have by Huang to go here and spare Yellow Crane Tower. Huang gone, clouds golden empty leisurely " several at unqualified law. The first sentence of the fourth word of the oblique tones with a level tone (multiplication), the sixth word level tone and oblique tones (Crane). The third sentence of the fourth five-word this level tone with the oblique tones (go, not). The fourth sentence of the fifth word this oblique tones, and with a level tone (empty). Meng Haoran "Spending the Night", "the shift boat mooring smoke Nagisa, Higurashi passengers unhappy new wild desert day low tree. The Jiang Qing Month neighbor." The first sentence there are two out of the law, the third word of the level tone and with oblique tones ("parked" the tone characters), the fourth word of the the oblique tones and with a level tone (smoke). Du Mu's "Qingming", "Tomb Sweeping Festival rain have, pedestrians Deep Sorrow by asking restaurants where, Yao Zhi Heng Fa Chuen shepherd." Into three words of the rhyme, "Fun, the soul, the village, the soul, and the village are 13 Yuan Yun, Fun word Twelve Ministry.
The above examples illustrate, poetry is good or bad, metrical requirements are not absolute. In other words, metrical does not prevent write good poetry, good poetry occasional breakthrough metrical. Any paranoid view, is not desirable.
Metrical, there is little need to pay attention: the metrical not static. For example, the word Shu, Ouyang Xiu, Su Shi Wang Anshi, Zeng Qingzhao simply more "read the poem Qing sentence," often do not co-temperament "pentameter six laws, voicing the severity not very particular about (reflected in its word '). But some of their exceptional usage, and have actually descendants of emulation and has become a new metrical form. The great Tang Dynasty poet Du Fu, Han Yu, deliberately heavy use of Ao grid (first guilty solitary level again figuratively rescue), in fact, is a new form of metrical poetry.
The of Liu Zhong seedlings Jun some works, such as "Songs of Chu", "Lingnan Song, metrical aspects, have failed to Jinzun at. Momentum, have feelings, content, sonorous syllable, meteorological magnificent. In a nutshell, there is a whiff of poetry. Liu Jun may wish to learn Su'm singing, do not have to be too concerned about the metrical faction of blame.